A bold, unusual and enthralling film from the talented Yorgos Lanthimos, Poor Things is probably his most ambitious film to date and for me one of his best. Fashioning a coming of age story about a woman’s journey of immense liberation, Lanthimos pulls you into an extraordinary world and movie filled with weirdness, heart and stellar acting, particularly from a never better Emma Stone.
In Victorian London, the scarred and eccentric surgeon Godwin Baxter(Willem Dafoe) takes on medical student Max McCandles ( Ramy Youssef) as an apprentice. When taken to the strange house of the man, Max doesn’t know what to expect. It is here that meets Bella Baxter ( Emma Stone), a most unusual young woman in house who Godwin treats like a daughter Godwin explains that he has resurrected Bella after it transpires she ended her life via drowning. She was pregnant at the time so he used the brain of her baby to bring her back to life. Bella is a grown woman who is first presented as the result of his experimentation. She acts like a young infant in mannerism and understanding, but she advances quicker than the average person as does her thirst for knowledge. Godwin loves her like a daughter, but never really lets her out of the house as he’s worried about what might happen because she’s not accustomed to the outside world yet. He is therefore delighted when he notices affection between Bella and Max. However, Bella is charmed by the irredeemable cad Duncan Wedderburn (Mark Ruffalo) who wants to whisk her off on an adventure , mainly for his own desires and amusement. Bella runs away with Duncan to explore the world, leaving Godwin and both longing for her return. After a trip through Lisbon in which Bella becomes difficult for him to handle , Wedderburn kidnaps her and takes her on a cruise ship. He eventually grows tired of how Bella is not as naive as she originally seemed to him and is progressing towards being her own person rapidly, particularly in the area of sexual and personal discovery. For Bella, life begins to open her eyes to things as she craves learning and defies the stifling conventions of the time, meeting many interesting characters along the way. Her sexual and literal liberation from society gallops away, leave most around her shocked, envious and baffled .It’s quite the journey as she begins to march to the beat of her own drum and become a woman in charge of her own destiny in a world that often questions it.
Over a number of years, Yorgos Lanthimos has become one of my favourite directors. I admire how he isn’t afraid to depict the strange, occasionally unexplainable yet always memorable on screen. And he most certainly doesn’t disappoint with Poor Things. Yorgos Lanthimos is on fire here , bringing his vision of self-actualisation and unusual coming of age to life with delightfully uncompromising brilliance and a mixture of unexpected depth and laugh out loud glee. Many moments of humour abound , particularly in a frantic out there dance scene and anytime Bella dares to say what we all want to say but are often to polite to utter . But underneath the surface is a depth of examination of societal pressure, discovering oneself and completely owning who you are in a world at odds with that concept of individuality. Much has been made of the film’s nudity and scenes of sex. But while they are prominent throughout Poor Things, I don’t believe that they are there for simple titillation. Bella’s sexual freedom and sense of emancipation from the role that women are supposed to play is integral to the story. So in that view the sex and nudity are important parts of Poor Things, for they chart her growth as a person and most importantly a woman of extreme agency.
On the visual side of events, Poor Things will blow your mind with what it does with cinematography and production design . From the unusual fish eye lens and black and white in the beginning to the eye popping colours of the journey, Poor Things takes us deep into a fantastically strange place that makes your jaw drop . And the sets are simply breathtaking and brimming with a steampunk spirit; see them on the big screen because the craftsmanship is simply extraordinary and you feel transported into this strange world right from the get go. I definitely believe award nominations will be arriving think and fast for the production and visual departments and deservedly so. Special mention must also go to the costume department, who pull out all the stops for fantastically off the clothing that fits the movie like a glove with loud, ruffled fabrics and imaginative textures. Apart from the occasional languor in pace, Poor Things is the kind of film that fires the imagination of a film reviewer like myself. The score from Jerskin Fendrix is also something completely weird and oddly fascinating. Piercing violin shrieks and rattling percussion craft a sense of childlike wonder giving way to maturity and grandiosity. Oddness is the order of the day in a score that has to be heard to be believed for its sheer volume and all encompassing grasp.
One of the best areas of Poor Things is the acting from a game cast that surrenders to the delightfully bonkers story. Emma Stone turns in the performance of her career as the searching Bella Baxter and is magnetic. Clearly enjoying her second collaboration with Lanthimos( their first being the viciously dark and caustically entertaining The Favourite), Stone proves the two are a dream team of star and director In the hands of a lesser performer, this performance could have turned into overly mannered and irritating. But in Stone’s more than capable hands, it becomes something alive and kinetic. Stone embodies the very physical position of someone whose faculties, at least in the beginning, don’t match the outer appearance. As she progresses, the slightly off kilter way of speaking, her ability to say things that people wouldn’t usually say and gait becomes integral to the plot as Bella discovers herself more and more. Emma Stone is all kinds of wonderful here; devilishly funny, alert , moving, ribald, forthright, alarming and charming. She charts the progress of Bella with all of the aforementioned qualities and a true understanding of a most fascinating character. I can’t praise this performance, but to summarise, Emma Stone is the beating heart of this immense saga and is simply extraordinary throughout Poor Things. Mark Ruffalo is masterfully funny as the Bon vivant who becomes infatuated with Bella but then can’t quite handle someone he can’t control. Ruffalo gives his role gusto, slippery wit and flashy zing ; becoming a fragile goofball in the process as his pursuit of pleasure comes crumbling down around him and he morphs into a pitiful man of vengeance. Willem Dafoe, who for me is always a reliable presence, doesn’t disappoint here as the unusual but caring scientist behind Bella’s resurrection. He’s both very witty at times yet filled with a barely contained sadness that threatens to come out. Ramy Youssef provides an innocence and certain wide eyed wonder as the medical student completely struck by the unstoppable Bella. Jerrod Carmichael, Hanna Schygulla and Kathryn Hunter all make impressions as people encountered by Bella on her odyssey, with Kathryn Hunter particularly being unforgettable in her short screen time as a Madame.
So with a wild sense of humour, striking visuals, terrific acting and directing from the ever eccentric Yorgos Lanthimos , Poor Things is a pretty unforgettable piece of cinema that definitely makes a mark on whoever views it. Expect much award notice for all involved in this movie as it’s an experience and then some.