Tags
1990's, Adrian Rawlins, Breaking the Waves, Drama, Emily Watson, Jean-Marc Barr, Katrin Cartlidge, Lars Von Trier, Stellan Skarsgård, Udo Kier
Film Title
Breaking the Waves
Director
Lars Von Trier
Starring
- Emily Watson as Bess McNeill
- Stellan Skarsgård as Jan
- Katrin Cartlidge as Dodo McNeill
- Jean-Marc Barr as Terry
- Adrian Rawlins as Dr. Richardson
- Udo Kier as Man on the trawler
Breaking the Waves is the devastating and very powerful story of faith, sacrifice and love. Crafted by Lars Von Trier, it doesn’t make for the easiest viewing but boasts an emotionally complex performance by Emily Watson and a dizzying visual style that haunt the mind.
Bess McNeill is a naive, childlike and devoutly religious girl brought up in an austere Scottish coastal town in the 1970’s. The elders of the town rule with a dogmatic power and are strictly religious to say the least, their actions include giving sinners a pauper’s funeral and not allowing women to voice opinions in church. Bess falls for Jan, an oil rig worker who is deemed as an outsider to the community. They eventually marry although this isn’t without a few eyebrows being raised. During the blissful days after their wedding, Bess is shown the love and sexual relationship that can be had between a couple. It is when Jan has to go back to his work that Bess finds it most difficult. She becomes distant and panics as she can’t bear to be without her beloved. She prays for his return from the rig. Jan does return yet not as Bess had hoped. He is severely injured in a working accident and most of his body is now rendered paralysed. Unable to sexually express his love to her, Jan asks Bess a strange question. He asks her to take other lovers and report back to him regarding the encounters, thereby making Jan feel like he is still a part of Bess. Bess is initially shocked by his question and refuses it. But she later becomes convinced that this will help Jan and so she goes out to perform these favours which start out innocent enough, but slowly evolve into dangerous and ultimately devastating consequences. Starkly powerful, uncomfortably shown and startling performed, Breaking the Waves makes for an uncompromising but astonishingly told story of the singular power of love and the horrifying sacrifices one is forced to make.
As is often the case with movies by Von Trier, Breaking the Waves is not for everyone and will polarize many. The grim quality to the story and the visual style won’t be for all audiences, but for those with a strong stomach it may be watchable. Von Trier employs a delirious, handheld camera to capture the escalating events that befall the beatific Bess. The colour appears to have been washed out which compliments the austere and horrifying community and its beliefs. A well-chosen soundtrack of 70’s rock and pop give the events a certain immediacy to the audience and provides a brief moment of happiness in the uncomfortable saga that soon arrives.
What really gives Breaking the Waves a haunting and shocking power is the emotionally shattering central performance from Emily Watson in her movie debut. She encompasses the pixie like innocence of Bess and the deep and heartfelt love that she holds for her husband. There isn’t one emotion that Watson doesn’t encompass in this story and her raw, intense and heartbreaking performance anchors the startling story. Whether crying out for Jan’s return, telling her doctor her talent, speaking to God in a childlike voice( before answering back in His voice) or marching up her strange path of martyrdom, Watson is a revelation. Stellan Skarsgård is well cast as Jan, bringing an alternate tenderness and strangeness to his role. Katrin Cartlidge and Adrian Rawlins provide stunning support as the best friend of Bess and her local doctor, who both begin to worry for Bess. Jean-Marc Barr provides some humour as one of Jan’s co-workers, while Udo Kier is frighteningly sadistic as a sailor.
Uncomfortable and shocking in equal measure, Breaking the Waves is also a heartbreaking and powerful saga of religion and the strange power of one woman’s love and the shocking consequences which arise as a result of it.
Great review! Never saw it but I do like Emily Watson and while a bizarre premise, I would give it a go 🙂
LikeLike
Thanks Cindy, Emily Watson is just so powerful to watch in this film.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You will never forget it, Cindy. that’s for sure!
LikeLiked by 2 people
An unforgettable and shattering debut.
LikeLike
Good review Vinnie. Possibly my favorite of von Triers. Which, then again, isn’t saying much, but still says enough. That makes sense, right?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, I understand what you mean. His films are not usually meant to be the most comfortable viewing.
LikeLike
Sounds dark but fascinating.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, it certainly is dark but I wouldn’t expect any less from Lars Von Trier.
LikeLike
I’d agree completely with that.
LikeLike
Thanks for commenting Alex.
LikeLike
great film as i recall (I haven’t seen it in years and years). I think Emily Watson is just a fantastic actress who unfortunately in the last few years seems to have been relegated to “kindly mother” roles.
LikeLike
Thanks for commenting. I love Emily Watson as an actress, she always invests so much emotion into her roles.
LikeLike
Just in time for the Criterion re-release 🙂 Good job Vinnie. Very well-written piece. Actually, in reading this it made me revisit the film. I wasn’t very familiar with Stellan Skarsgård’s work up until that point, but I’m a big fan now. Although it’s not one of those films that’s easy to re-watch as you know..
LikeLike
Thanks, Skarsgard is a really good actor who has consistently given great performances.
LikeLike
Sounds like the kind of movie I’d be into to. Thanks for the heads up! 🙂
LikeLike
Thanks for the comment, let me know your thoughts if you manage to see it.
LikeLike
Hello! Here’s a survey of Lars Von Trier’s career, by Linda Badley, you might be interested in taking a look:
http://awestruckwanderer.wordpress.com/2014/04/11/lars-von-trier-60-genius-40-fraud/
Cheers!
LikeLike
Thanks, I will definitely take a look at the survey, thanks for the link.
LikeLike
Great review. I’ve tried to watch this but its just so grim! I need to be in the proper mood to watch the whole thing
LikeLike
Thanks for the comment, I understand what you mean. You need to be in a certain frame of mind when watching a Von Trier movie.
LikeLike
Great review! Von Trier’s works are clearly not made to be seen by everyone but those visual effects and the style that he delivers to each one of his movies makes them really special. Thanks to your review, I’ve decided to add “Breaking the Waves” to my watchlist, not only for looking interesting but also because it stars an actor that got my attention in Nymph()maniac: Stellan Skarsgard!
LikeLike
Appreciate the comment, glad my review has made you add it to your watchlist.
LikeLike
You’re welcome! I am also looking forward to watch “Dancer in the Dark” and “Melancholia”.
LikeLike
Melancholia was a great film in my book, I haven’t seen Dancer in the Dark yet but plan to see it when I can.
LikeLike
Great review! I know how polarizing Lars Von Trier is so I may give this film a try. Although I did find Anti-Christ just a depressing watch.
LikeLike
Also I nominated you for a Liebster award 🙂
LikeLike
Thanks, very much appreciated.
LikeLike
Thanks, polarising is what Von Trier is very good at being.
LikeLike
Good review. I pretty much agree with your analysis. “Breaking the Waves” is probably my favorite of Von Trier’s work. His obsession with sex, the female psyche, and relationships is seamlessly composed here. Thanks in part to Watson’s and Skarsgard’s incredible performances. There’re a lot of layers that can be unpacked in this film, and I would like to revisit it in the context of some of Von Trier’s other works.
LikeLike
It really is a startling and hauntingly powerful movie with as you said so many layers to it.
LikeLike
I just don’t like Von Trier I’m afraid.
LikeLike
I can completely understand what you mean, his movies are not for everyone because of their often startling content.
LikeLike
Great stuff Vinnie. It’s a tough watch but a brilliant movie all the same. Watson is an absolute revelation and thoroughly deserved her Oscar nomination.
LikeLike
Thanks for commenting Mark. Emily Watson is just so powerful and utterly heartbreaking in her portrayal of Bess.
LikeLike
Great review man! Seen most of Von Trier’s work now and this is definitely one of my favourites. So powerful and Watson is beyond incredible. Hit the nail on the head with the discussion about her performance.
LikeLike
Thanks for commenting. Watson just gives her full body and soul to the role and the results are staggeringly powerful.
LikeLike
This and Dancer in The Dark are my two favourite Von Trier films. His work can be hard to define, and equally hard to like on occasion. This film is held together by an amazing performance by Emily Watson in the lead. The subject matter is hardly comfortable, but I suppose that’s the whole point of the film. She shines throughout though, undeniably.
Good review V.
Regards, Pete.
LikeLiked by 1 person
His movies are very draining but unforgettable at the same time. I have yet to see Dancer in the Dark so thanks for the reminder Pete. As you said Watson is a powerhouse here, just so devastating and staggeringly powerful.
LikeLike
Bjork and Deneuve are great to watch. It’s a sad film though V.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s been added to my watch list.
LikeLike
Pingback: A Few More Old Reviews – vinnieh
Pingback: You’ve Been Tagged | vinnieh