Tags
1990's, Al Pacino, Comedy, Drama, Frankie and Johnny, Garry Marshall, Hector Elizondo, Kate Nelligan, Michelle Pfeiffer, Nathan Lane, Romance
Film Title
Frankie and Johnny
Director
Garry Marshall
Cast
- Al Pacino as Johnny
- Michelle Pfeiffer as Frankie
- Hector Elizondo as Nick
- Nathan Lane as Tim
- Kate Nelligan as Cora
- Jane Morris as Nedda
A funny and often touching tale of two people falling hesitantly in love, Frankie and Johnny is a romantic comedy drama boasting great performances and a poignant screenplay that pierces to the heart of the meaning of love for different people.
Johnny is a middle-aged men who has just been released from prison. He has an exceptional talent for cooking and whilst searching for a job is hired by Nick, the Greek owner of a busy diner in Manhattan. It is here that Johnny first lays eyes upon Frankie, a plain waitress who tries to keep emotional attachments at arm’s length. He is immediately smitten and tries to woo the distant Frankie, finding it will be a hard task to convince her that love exists as she seems to turn him down every time he tries to express himself. Through his relentless pursuit of her, he gradually gets her to emerge from her shell and speak of why she doesn’t like attachment. Prepare for funny and soul-searching moments as they gradually see the good in each other in this warm, romantic comedy.
As the happy, hungry for life Johnny, Al Pacino shows a flair for comedy as we watch his various declarations of love met with a no. He has excellent chemistry with Michelle Pfeiffer, and provides their scenes with a dramatic and tender charm. At the time of the film’s release, much was made by critics of Michelle Pfeiffer being “too pretty” for the role of the lonely and forlorn Frankie. Yet I disagree, as she adeptly rises to the challenge and creates a beautifully touching performance, filled with a dejected melancholy and vulnerability that eventually gives way to hope. Standout’s from the supporting cast include Hector Elizondo as the manager of the diner, Nathan Lane as Frankie’s gay neighbour who wants the best for his close friend and Kate Nelligan as the sassy, gum-chewing waitress Cora, whose discussions with Frankie regarding men are hysterical to watch. Garry Marshall manages to sidestep some of the usual formula involved in romantic comedies to form a tender love story that will make you laugh but touch your heart deeply, sometimes at the same time. Adapting from his own play, Terrence McNally fills the film with comedic and equally insights into the ways the heart works when it comes to love. This is most evident in the way he writes the scenes in which Johnny tries to impress Frankie with his knowledge of Shakespeare and old music. When he mentions that th
ey were made for each other because their names also are the title of a song, she replies “Didn’t they end up killing each other”? Johnny’s hilarious answer to this is “No she killed him, so I’ve got the edge there”. This is one of many witty and loving sparks of dialogue that appear throughout the film to give it a tender but never cloying examination of hesitant romance.
Witty, warm and tinged with subtle melancholy, Frankie and Johnny provides excellent roles for the cast, sparkling chemistry between Al Pacino and Michelle Pfeiffer and makes an emotional connection with the audience, making the material very relatable.
Nice review; I hadn’t heard of this film at all. Though I do think that describing Michelle Pfeiffer as “plain” seems a bit …wrong, but that’s without seeing the film!
LikeLike
Thanks, yeah Pfeiffer is gorgeous but is made to look dowdy in this film. The film really shows her versatility as an actress.
LikeLike
Very different from the Terrence McNally play upon which it is based, I still find this film to be somewhat underrated. In a career littered with some pretty horrendous films…this is one of Gary Marshall’s good ones. ML
LikeLike
Thanks for your comment.
LikeLike
They reunited their chemistry from Scarface, and I’m glad. Pfeiffer shows she can act here, and well, Al Pacino is Al. His diverse skill keeps me coming back for more. NIce review!
LikeLike
Thanks, yeah their chemistry is great in this.
LikeLike
Nice one Vinnie. I don’t normally go for these types of movies but I really enjoyed this one. Good write-up, man.
LikeLike
Thanks Mark, yeah I’m not usually a rom com guy but I make an exception with this film.
LikeLike
Frankie and Johnny is an entrancing, profoundly romantic film that has been wrongly maligned over the years. Thanks for balancing the scales.
For the record Michelle’s amazingly deft work in this film makes it my favourite Pfeiffer performance of all .
She is simply, unarguably excellent, despite what anyone wants to say about the movie itself. After all the fracas where people thought she was too pretty to play the part, her Frankie is utterly defensive but also extremely likeable, and she makes the whole movie feel real. Her impatience during the “open your robe” moment is classic Pfeiffer.
Keep the Pfeiffer content coming, it’s always a pleasure to read your thoughts.
LikeLike
Thanks, will probably review more of her films as I am a fan of her work.
LikeLike
Great cast! I had forgotten about this film. Thanks for reminding me about it.
LikeLike
No problems, it certainly has got a great cast.
LikeLike
I remember liking this one. Haven’t seen it in years, but it’s a good one.
LikeLike
Thanks for the comment, it had been a long time since I last saw it before I watched it recently. Still as good as it was the first time I saw it.
LikeLike
I remember this movie from a long, long time ago. This film had a different dynamic to it in comparison to Scarface where both Pacino and Pfeiffer also starred. Pacino’s an interesting actor. He can play one of the most brutal characters on screen, but then turn around in another movie and blow us away with a touching portrayal of the everyday man. If you’ve never seen the movie Author! Author!, he’s amazing in it. And it’s a comedy!
LikeLike
Thanks, I’m a big fan of Al Pacino so I’ll have to check out Author Author. Thanks for the recommendation.
LikeLike
Frankie and Johnny is a film I endured as a child (thanks to my mother) but have learnt to love as an adult. Like you so eloquently described in your review the connection and chemistry between Pfieffier and Pacino is at times electric and the film has a charm that is missing all to often in genre films of today. Great Review yet again Vinnieh
LikeLike
Thank you very much, glad you liked reading my review.
LikeLike
I’m so pleased to read that you were moved and convinced by Michelle Pfeiffer’s sensitive and truthful performance – I totally agree with your assessment and was indignant at the time with the critics for being so stupid and patronising about her beauty distracting from the character. Of course someone can be beautiful and unfortunate!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I love Pfeiffer, one of my favourite actresses.
LikeLike
The reveal scene about what happened to her makes me cry each time I watch. Michelle makes you feel Frankie’s pain and fear of trusting someone again. I love their slow build relationship, and I love how he tries to help her and find out what’s wrong. I consider this a pretty underrated flick. Al and Michelle are terrific together.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I always want to give her a hug when it comes to that part. And Michelle and Al really sold the slow and tentative relationship that built.
LikeLiked by 1 person